The assault on professional services

HomeInsights

The assault on professional services. 


Two new cases before the Administrative Appeals Tribunal demonstrate how serious the Australian Taxation Office (ATO) is about making sure professional services firms - lawyers, accountants, architects, medical practices, engineers, architects etc., – are appropriately taxed.  


In both cases, the ATO pursued the practices using Part IVA. Part IVA is an area of the income tax law that enables the Tax Commissioner to attack schemes or arrangements undertaken to obtain a tax benefit, enabling him to cancel any benefit derived by the scheme.


That is, you could have a legally viable structure in place but if the only purpose of that structure is to reduce tax, then the Commissioner can use Part IVA to remove the tax benefit. And, if Part IVA applies, you may end up with an additional tax liability as well as an administrative penalty of either 25% or 50% of the tax shortfall amount.


Broadly, the cases involved a solicitor who controlled a number of practice trusts that derived profits through marketing and facilitating tax planning arrangements.


While the arrangement in each case was complex and involved a large number of steps, the practice trusts ensured their business profits weren’t subject to tax by essentially making trust distributions on paper through a series of trusts and ultimately to either a company that had existing tax losses, or a tax-exempt entity.


However, the real funds relating to the trust distribution (less a commission paid for the use of these entities) were ultimately received by the solicitor or their associated entities in the form of a loan.


Professional practices have been in the ATO spotlight for many years now for the way they distribute profits. Back in 2021, the ATO finalised its guidance on the allocation of professional firm profits, putting in place a series of risk ratings and gateway tests.


These two cases however demonstrate the ATO’s willingness to pursue the issue in the courts using the Commissioner’s powers in Part IVA.


For professional services firms, it’s important to be aware that there are several ways in which the ATO can potentially challenge arrangements involving the distribution of profits from a professional practice. For example:

  • If a trading e ntity derives personal services income that mainly relates to the skills and efforts of a particular individual, the ATO has certain expectations around ensuring the profits are assessed to the individual performing the work. 
  • If a trading entity doesn’t derive personal services income but income from a business structure involving a professional practice, the ATO has set out its compliance approach to targeting arrangements that don’t result in a reasonable level of profit being taxed in the hands of the individual practitioners.
  • If a trust makes paper distributions to loss entities to ‘soak up’ deductions or losses, there are integrity rules in section 100A, another area of tax law under intense scrutiny, that need to be considered.



Need help? 

Smart Business Solutions Group is happy to provide a closer look at your current data to help you find more savings. We provide tailored services that allows you to get better results.


CONTACT US CONTACT US


22 Nov

6 steps to improve your credit rating for equipment financing

A good credit score can lead to better loan terms, lower interest rates and smoother approval processes.


READ MORE READ MORE
20 Nov

Can Asset Finance Help Startups?

Asset finance can be a powerful tool for startups looking to purchase equipment and technology without using up their cash reserves.


READ MORE READ MORE
18 Nov

Luxury retail drives cbd revival as sydney leads the pack

Sydney has emerged as Australia's retail powerhouse, while office markets across the country continue to face challenges.


READ MORE READ MORE
15 Nov

Investors Target Charity-Backed Commercial Assets

Commercial properties leased to established charities are emerging as highly sought-after investments. 


READ MORE READ MORE
13 Nov

Commercial construction reaches record levels as residential slows

Australia's construction sector, with commercial and infrastructure projects reaching record levels while residential development declines.


READ MORE READ MORE
4 Nov

Education Bonds: Saving for Private School

Darren and Jenny have one child and are planning for his secondary education at a Melbourne private school. Utilising education bonds, they aim to ensure they have sufficient funds to cover all tuition fees and associated costs throughout his education.


READ MORE READ MORE
4 Nov

Navigating Australia’s Bracket Creep: Strategies for Managing Rising Tax Liabilities

As Australia's highest marginal tax bracket impacts more individuals, a growing number of Australians face rising tax obligations due to "bracket creep," where wage growth outpaces tax rate adjustments. This trend is expected to persist, with tax-efficient strategies the backbone for financial advice to help individuals secure long-term wealth.


READ MORE READ MORE
30 Oct

5 things to know about car loan refinancing

Car loan refinancing involves replacing your existing car loan with a new one. The new loan pays off your existing debt, allowing you to start making payments on the refinanced car loan.


READ MORE READ MORE
28 Oct

How to apply for a car loan with a new job

Lenders often view job stability and income consistency as key factors in their loan approval process, which can make it tricky if you're settling into a new role.


READ MORE READ MORE
25 Oct

5 important steps before making an offer

Making an offer on a property for the first time is both exciting and nerve-racking. It’s important to take several steps to ensure you’re making a well-informed decision


READ MORE READ MORE
24 Oct

Market Wrap - September 2024

The presidential election in the US on 5 November could dominate headlines during October, before the next meeting of the Federal Reserve later that same week. Investors are already debating whether a further reduction in borrowing costs in the US could be announced following this meeting.


READ MORE READ MORE
21 Oct

Melbourne's housing prices fall to the sixth lowest among the capital cities

Melbourne's housing market has experienced a significant shift in recent years, with its median dwelling value now ranking sixth-lowest among Australia's capital cities.


READ MORE READ MORE
18 Oct

6 common refinancing traps to avoid

Refinancing your home loan can be a great way to save money, but it’s important to avoid common pitfalls.


READ MORE READ MORE
16 Oct

7 tips for styling your spring open home

Spring is a popular time to sell homes, with warmer weather and blooming gardens creating an inviting atmosphere that brings out the best of any property.


READ MORE READ MORE
14 Oct

Smart Financial Planning for New Parents: 9 Essential Tips to Manage Parenthood Costs

Discover 9 essential financial planning tips to help new and expecting parents manage the costs of parenthood with confidence and ease.


READ MORE READ MORE
11 Oct

The hidden costs of late payments

Cash flow is the lifeblood of any business and when payments are delayed, it creates an immediate strain.


READ MORE READ MORE
9 Oct

6 misconceptions about small business loans.

Small business loans are often misunderstood. These misconceptions can prevent owners from taking advantage of valuable opportunities to grow their businesses.


READ MORE READ MORE
7 Oct

Luxury retail drives cbd revival as sydney leads the pack

Australia's CBD retail markets are showing signs of recovery post-pandemic with luxury brands leading the charge.


READ MORE READ MORE
4 Oct

Commercial property cycle offers opportunities for investors

There are still excellent opportunities for commercial investors in retail and industrial sectors thanks to the current property cycle.


READ MORE READ MORE
2 Oct

Business growth signals positive outlook for commercial property

The Australian business landscape is expanding, signalling a potentially strong future for commercial property markets.


READ MORE READ MORE
24 Sep

SMART Life - Issue 18 - Spring 2024

The global economy is being shaped by conflicting triggers. These include productivity-boosting technology innovations, geopolitical tensions and the strident efforts of central banks to bring inflation under control. We examine the economic outlook and discuss the implications for your retirement savings.


READ MORE READ MORE
19 Sep

Episode 15: Baby Boomers & The Great Wealth Transfer

In this episode of The Accountant That Builds, host Shannon Smit discusses the massive wealth transfer expected from Baby Boomers to the next generation, estimated at $84 trillion. Shannon highlights the opportunities and challenges of this transfer, focusing on estate planning, tax liabilities


READ MORE READ MORE
19 Sep

The Great Wealth Transfer: What Baby Boomers Need to Know About Preserving and Passing Down Wealth

Over the coming years, we’re about to witness the largest wealth transfer in history as Baby Boomers pass their hard-earned fortunes to younger generations. With an estimated $84 trillion set to be transferred, mostly from savings, investments, and real estate, this shift holds both incredible opportunities and significant challenges for families.


READ MORE READ MORE
19 Sep

Understanding the Taxable Payments Annual Report (TPAR): A Guide for Australian Businesses

The Taxable Payments Annual Report (TPAR) is a mandatory report for Australian businesses in certain industries to disclose contractor payments to the ATO by August 28 each year, ensuring accurate tax reporting.


READ MORE READ MORE
18 Sep

Will You Pay More For Aged Care in 2025?

Changes to aged care fees are coming, and they will impact both home care and residential care. After a long wait and lots of speculation, the government has released details of the proposed changes.


READ MORE READ MORE
16 Sep

Aged Care Financial Advice Case Studies

Our aged-care financial advice case studies showcase real scenarios where our clients saved thousands by leveraging strategies regarding the family home, negotiating RADs and optimising care facility choices.


READ MORE READ MORE
11 Sep

Super Guarantee and Employee Terminations: Compliance Essentials for Employers

WEBINAR 11 SEPT // 12PM

In the third session, we'll delve into superannuation guarantee changes, including proposed changes to payday superannuation, new rates and bases, and the impact on SG liability. Gain insights into employer deductions, termination of employment considerations and more.


READ MORE READ MORE
11 Sep

How to record bad debts in Xero


READ MORE READ MORE
11 Sep

How to record incorrect payment against an invoice in Xero


READ MORE READ MORE
4 Sep

Allowances, FBT, and Compliance for Employers

WEBINAR 4 SEPT // 12PM

Master allowances and reimbursements, understand their PAYG and super guarantee implications, and learn to navigate travel vs. living-away-from-home allowances. Gain insights into FBT considerations, new ATO record-keeping requirements, and effective salary packaging arrangements.


READ MORE READ MORE



Related News

4 Nov

Navigating Australia’s Bracket Creep: Strategies for Managing Rising Tax Liabilities

As Australia's highest marginal tax bracket impacts more individuals, a growing number of Australians face rising tax obligations due to "bracket creep," where wage growth outpaces tax rate adjustments. This trend is expected to persist, with tax-efficient strategies the backbone for financial advice to help individuals secure long-term wealth.


READ MORE READ MORE
14 Oct

Smart Financial Planning for New Parents: 9 Essential Tips to Manage Parenthood Costs

Discover 9 essential financial planning tips to help new and expecting parents manage the costs of parenthood with confidence and ease.


READ MORE READ MORE
19 Sep

Understanding the Taxable Payments Annual Report (TPAR): A Guide for Australian Businesses

The Taxable Payments Annual Report (TPAR) is a mandatory report for Australian businesses in certain industries to disclose contractor payments to the ATO by August 28 each year, ensuring accurate tax reporting.


READ MORE READ MORE